Comic Book Critics

Supergirl #40

7.1
Out of 10
Critic Reviews: 7
User Comments: 0
Buy Now at TFAW
Supergirl #40 Supergirl #40

Written by
Art by and
Cover by Joshua Middleton
Size: 32 Pages
Price: $2.99

Summary

“Who is Superwoman?” part 4! Following last issue, Supergirl must decide what to do with a shocking piece of information that casts all of “New Krypton” in a new light! Meanwhile, Lois begins putting together clues regarding the body found in Metropolis Harbor and the strange message it was broadcasting.

Supergirl #40 Reviews

All critic scores are converted to a 10-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...


6
by Kirk Warren Weekly Crisis
Avoid It. There are moments I liked this issue, but the absurdity of the reveal and some heavy handed writing really knock the wind out my sails in regards to my enthusiasm for this title.
Read Full Review

8.3
by Ryan the Iowan Weekly Review Power Rankings
It’s amazing how much of a turnaround this series has seen under Gates and Igle. This issue is no different; it’s that level of quality that makes this one a can’t miss issue.
Read Full Review

6.7
by Dan Phillips IGN
As a mystery, I don't think the whole ""Who is Superwoman"" arc holds up very well. Gates more or less just dropped a bunch of red herrings and bait and switche
Read Full Review

8
by CaptHowdy Comic Vine
Still, this series is on a high note right now. I've followed it ever since the beginning and the current storyline is one of the most interesting Supergirl ones I've read in a long time.
Read Full Review

8.2
by Average User Rating iFanboy
Pick of the Week Percentage: 0.6%
Read Full Review

7
by Stephen Schieicher Major Spoilers
Supergirl #40 delivered on the promise of revealing the identity of Superwoman, and is good enough to earn 3.5 out of 5 Stars.
Read Full Review

6
by Jill a.k.a. The Nerdy Bird Girls Entertainment Network
It’s just such a relief the title finally has some real direction under Sterling Gates. The extended cast of characters for Supergirl is definitely something the book was lacking and what brings it on par with the rest of DC’s super books.
Read Full Review

Leave a Response