Comic Book Critics

Uncanny X-Men #510

7.1
Out of 10
Critic Reviews: 9
User Comments: 0
Buy Now at TFAW
Uncanny X-Men #510

WRITER:
PENCILS:
INKS:
COLORED BY: JUSTIN PONSOR
LETTERED BY: VC – JOE CARAMAGNA
COVER BY:
Price: $2.99

Summary

SIEGE! The Sisterhood executes a massive raid on the Graymalkin Facility, taking their fight to the Uncanny X-Men, and you won’t believe the ferocity. No one is safe! Everybody fights! But why? How? What do they want? And how long can violence at such an insane level last? Oh, about most of the issue.

Uncanny X-Men #510 Reviews

All critic scores are converted to a 10-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...


7.5
by Bryan Joel IGN
If you can get past the whole art debacle, there's a fantastic issue of Uncanny X-Men underneath. I doubt the days of dial-a-storyline are behind us, but for now I'm enjoying Matt Fraction's calmer approach to storytelling this issue.
Read Full Review

5.0
by David Wallace Comics Bulletin
This is a fairly forgettable issue that virtually ignores the only part of the book that I was still interested in... in favour of a bland fight sequence that doesn't carry any emotional weight for me due to my lack of history with the characters involved.
Read Full Review

10
by Nick S. Independent Comics Site
If you like the X-Men, and aren't reading this, you're either blind, stupid, or dead. Pick it up! NOW!
Read Full Review

8.0
by frpbsp Wolverine Files
Over all this was a solid issue with a number of good moments especially for Wolverine and Pixie. The setup for the next issue is amazing and I can not wait to see what they do with Jean’s hair.
Read Full Review

6.5
by Kyle Posluszny Weekly Comic Book Review
The book isn’t a total loss though, thanks to the ending and a few worthwhile panels, but it could have been a whole hell of a lot better.
Read Full Review

6.2
by Average User Rating iFanboy
385 Pulls, iFanboy Community Pick of the Week Percentage: 0.13%
Read Full Review

8.8
by Chuck Chuck's Comic of the Day
At any rate, the comic continues its slow road to improvement, and big events are in the offing for next issue. And just in time - we haven't had a good comic book resurrection in months!
Read Full Review

7.5
by John Carle The Flickcast
Between Land’s artwork, Fraction’s superb understanding of the characters and the A-Bomb level sized reveal at the end of the issue, Uncanny X-Men is one of the more shining books on a somewhat average week.
Read Full Review

4.0
by Ryan the Iowan Weekly Review Power Rankings
I’m sure Matt Fraction isn’t reading this, but in the off-chance that he is, I want to apologize for being so hard on this issue. I really dig the writing, but this is Land at his worst and I just can’t get passed that.
Read Full Review

Leave a Response